You Can’t Read a Playbook You’ve Never Been Given

Why your partner isn’t a mind reader — and neither are you.

A catcher can flash a few fingers and the pitcher knows exactly what pitch is being called. A quarterback can change a play with a word, a gesture, or a look.

But that only works because everybody learned the playbook first.

In relationships, we often skip that part.

We assume:

He should know what that look means.
She knows when I get quiet I need space.
If I walk away, obviously I’m trying not to make it worse.
When I sigh like that, how can you not know I’m hurt?

And the other person may genuinely be thinking:

I have absolutely no idea what signal you’re throwing at me.

That gets you beautifully into the larger teaching:

Nonverbal communication is still communication — but it isn’t automatically shared communication.

A signal only works reliably when both people understand what it means.

And there’s your connection to Tone, Timing & Trust™ too. The same gesture can mean give me a minute, leave me alone, I’m furious, I’m hurt, or I’m done depending on the relationship and the moment.

So perhaps one of the real relationship questions becomes:

Have we ever actually talked about what our signals mean?

Next
Next

Why You Stop Sounding Like Yourself During a Fight